Cracking the Code to Actuarial AI: A Game-Changer or Overhyped Trend?

December 03, 2024

Estimated Reading Time: 5 minutes

Artificial Intelligence (AI) is one of the most discussed and debated topics in today’s technological landscape, sparking curiosity and skepticism across various industries. In the actuarial profession, where precision, data-driven models, and long-standing methodologies are essential, AI’s potential impact is both exciting and daunting. Can AI revolutionize the way actuaries perform their work, or is the hype overstated? This article explores the role of AI in the actuarial field, the opportunities it offers, the challenges it presents, and its transformative potential.

AI’s influence is already being felt in numerous industries, including finance, healthcare, and insurance. It is reshaping business practices, customer interactions, and the very frameworks through which decisions are made. But within the actuarial profession, there are questions regarding AI's ability to live up to its promises. While some herald AI as a revolutionary force, others view it with caution. Will AI truly change the actuarial landscape, or is it an overblown trend?

AI's Role in Actuarial Work: Efficiency Over Revolution

AI in the actuarial profession is primarily viewed as a tool to enhance efficiency rather than fundamentally change core actuarial methodologies. AI’s ability to analyze vast datasets quickly, detect patterns, and automate repetitive tasks offers actuaries the opportunity to improve workflow and productivity. However, AI is unlikely to completely overhaul actuarial practices. Instead, it augments traditional methods, streamlining processes that were once time-consuming and labor-intensive.

Generative AI, for instance, is already being used to automate documentation tasks, such as generating reports and drafting code, allowing actuaries to focus more on the strategic aspects of their work. Such advances in efficiency not only save time but also reduce human error, ensuring more accurate and reliable outputs. However, it is important to note that AI’s impact lies more in enhancing existing practices than in replacing them. In the pricing and reserving functions, AI tools complement traditional methods like chain-ladder models and generalized linear models (GLMs), offering more granular insights and predictive power1 .

AI can also improve the personalization of insurance products. Using machine learning algorithms, actuaries can refine risk segmentation, allowing insurers to tailor their offerings to individual customers more effectively. This shift toward hyper-personalized pricing and coverage options could help insurers gain a competitive edge by offering more accurate products based on real-time data, such as from telematics or wearable devices.

AI in Actuarial Methodology: From Predictive Analytics to Improved Pricing

One of AI’s greatest strengths lies in its ability to manage large datasets and uncover patterns that may be difficult for traditional statistical methods to detect. Actuaries, who are experts in statistical analysis, are increasingly incorporating machine learning (ML) techniques into their methodologies, particularly in pricing and reserving.

AI-powered methods, such as deep learning and ensemble models, can provide better predictive accuracy compared to classical techniques. For example, in mortality forecasting, AI models can utilize vast amounts of data to create more accurate predictions, potentially improving the precision of insurance products. This allows actuaries to make better-informed decisions and optimize product offerings based on dynamic data sources.

Moreover, AI can bring improvements to reserving practices. While traditional reserving methods rely on historical claims data, AI can analyze additional variables, such as underwriting factors, environmental data, and market trends, to predict future claims more effectively. This predictive capability could improve the accuracy of reserve setting and ensure that insurance companies have adequate capital to cover potential liabilities.

Regulations are here to stay; and so are actuaries

Actuaries work not just in improving business outcomes but in capacity decided by the regulators as well as acting as experts for auditors. Regulators play a major role in insurance markets and AI will be no different. The main consideration for regulators for AI will be that it should have traceable results and not black boxes where we can’t explain the results of how the model arrived at what outcome. The regulators will also be concerned that technology and AI should not be used to hinge on ethics and lead to unethical outcomes such as using tech to treat customers unfairly. FCA UK for instance, has led to massive investigation in UK online pricing in 2022 that up to 400 pricing factors were used to decide upon premiums including irrelevant factors like what browser was used, what time was the page opened and so on.

So regulatory concerns are not going anywhere and its not like AI will lead to removal of regulators and completely free markets. As long as regulations will be there, there will be need to analyze and clarify on insurance quantitative elements which actuaries specialize in. Regulators can slow down the speed but they can also act as catalysts for innovation in the right way by making regulatory sandbox and allowing innovation via the sandbox path.

The Challenges of AI Adoption in Actuarial Science

Despite the promising applications of AI in actuarial work, its adoption presents several challenges. One significant issue is the opacity of many AI models. While traditional actuarial models like GLMs are relatively transparent, allowing actuaries to understand how each variable impacts the outcome, many AI models, especially deep learning models, are often seen as "black boxes." This lack of interpretability raises concerns, particularly in regulated industries where transparency is critical for compliance and auditability.

Several researchers and practitioners are working on ways to bridge this gap. For example, techniques like SHAP (Shapley Additive Explanations) are being explored to make machine learning models more interpretable, allowing actuaries to understand how certain inputs contribute to the final predictions2 . Nevertheless, this challenge of interpretability must be addressed if AI is to be fully embraced in actuarial applications.

Another concern is the risk of bias in AI models. AI systems learn from data, and if the data used to train these models contains biases, the AI will inevitably inherit and perpetuate them. In the context of pricing, this could lead to discriminatory practices. For example, if historical claims data reflects biased practices in underwriting or pricing, the AI model may unintentionally perpetuate these biases, resulting in unfair outcomes. Actuaries, who are well-versed in fairness and equity in pricing, are well-positioned to identify and mitigate these biases, ensuring AI’s use is ethical and compliant with regulatory standards3 .

Moreover, there is a gap in training. While actuaries have a deep understanding of statistical models and risk management, AI and machine learning techniques are often not part of the standard actuarial curriculum. This presents a barrier to widespread adoption, as actuaries may lack the expertise needed to develop or interpret AI models. As the profession evolves, actuaries will need to acquire new skills in data science and machine learning to effectively incorporate AI into their work4 .

AI and the Future of Actuarial Science: A Hybrid Approach

Looking ahead, the future of AI in actuarial science is likely to be hybrid in nature. Rather than replacing actuaries, AI will serve as a tool to enhance their capabilities. This hybrid approach will allow actuaries to leverage AI’s strengths, its ability to process large amounts of data, uncover hidden patterns, and automate routine tasks, while still relying on their judgment and expertise in interpreting results and making strategic decisions.

Several scenarios envision this hybrid future. According to the Casualty Actuarial Society (CAS), actuaries may evolve into “data science professionals” who blend traditional actuarial techniques with AI-powered tools to provide more accurate, data-driven insights. These actuaries will become central figures in decision-making processes, working closely with data scientists and other technical professionals to implement AI solutions and interpret their outputs5 .

In this scenario, actuaries will focus on high-value tasks, such as identifying emerging risks, designing new products, and improving customer experiences, while AI handles the heavy lifting of data analysis and process automation. The rise of AI will enable actuaries to focus more on innovation and strategy, expanding their role in shaping the future of insurance.

AI's Transformative Potential in Actuarial Work

Beyond its immediate applications in pricing, reserving, and risk management, AI holds the potential to transform the actuarial profession in deeper ways. One of the most significant transformations is the potential for real-time, dynamic risk assessment. With AI-powered tools, actuaries could continuously analyze real-time data from a variety of sources, such as sensor data, market trends, and social media, to provide up-to-date risk assessments.

This shift towards continuous risk assessment would represent a profound change in the way actuaries approach their work. It would enable insurers to respond more quickly to emerging risks, adjust their pricing in real-time, and offer products that are more closely aligned with current conditions. The ability to dynamically adjust to new information would greatly enhance the responsiveness and resilience of insurance companies in a rapidly changing world.

Conclusion

AI’s integration into the actuarial profession is poised to bring significant changes. While it is unlikely to replace actuaries, it will fundamentally enhance their capabilities, enabling them to work more efficiently, make more accurate predictions, and develop more personalized products. However, for AI to reach its full potential, actuaries must address challenges such as model interpretability, bias, and training gaps. By adopting a hybrid approach that blends AI’s strengths with human expertise, actuaries can ensure that AI serves as a valuable tool in their work, rather than a threat to their profession.

AI represents both an opportunity and a challenge for the actuarial profession. If actuaries embrace AI’s potential, they will be well-positioned to lead the industry in the future of insurance.

 1 .The Actuary, "AI: A Genuine Gamechanger or Overblown Hype?" September 5, 2024.

2 "An AI Vision for the Actuarial Profession." eForum, Casualty Actuarial Society, 2023

3. Intersecting AI and Actuarial Science: The Interview, Casualty Actuarial Society, 2023

4 ."An AI Vision for the Actuarial Profession." eForum, Casualty Actuarial Society, 2023

5 ."Four Futures for Actuaries in the Wake of AI," Casualty Actuarial Society, 2023

Useful resources for further reading

How do you think AI will impact the actuarial profession?

Login or Subscribe to participate in polls.